Montauk, NY 5 Bedroom Homes For Rent | Out East

Skip to content

Rent
Buy
Stories
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner

For Rent by Owner
Sign In Sign Up

Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
- For Sale by Owner
- For Rent by Owner

Rentals
The Hamptons
Montauk

Montauk, NY 5 Bedroom Homes For Rent

56 Results

Pool
Active
$275,000
(July)
8Bd
7.5Ba
1.01Acr
5.14KSq Ft
Montauk
42 Deforest Rd
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
Pool
Active
$225,000
(July)
6Bd
5.5Ba
1Acr
4.8KSq Ft
Montauk
40 Deforest Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
South of highway
Active
$35,000
(August - Labor Day)
5Bd
4.5Ba
0.21Acr
3.26KSq Ft
Montauk
47 Lincoln Rd
Listing by Compass
Active
$36,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
2Ba
Montauk
21 Hoppin Ave
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$160,000
(August - Labor Day)
6Bd
7.5Ba
0.5Acr
6.07KSq Ft
Montauk
250 East Lake Dr
Listing by Martha Greene Real Estate llc
Pool
Active
$235,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
3Ba
0.8Acr
2.9KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
Active
$210,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
5Ba
1.6Acr
4.1KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$20,000
(September)
6Bd
3Ba
0.33Acr
2.2KSq Ft
Montauk
323 Flamingo Ave
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$75,000
(August - Labor Day)
5Bd
5.5Ba
Montauk
96 Benson Dr
Listing by Compass
Pool
Active
$90,000
(September)
6Bd
5.5Ba
1.5Acr
6.02KSq Ft
Montauk
15 Wills Point Rd
Listing by The Agency
Pool
Active
$25,000
(Short-Term)
5Bd
4Ba
0.17Acr
2.7KSq Ft
Montauk
2 Lee Ct
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
Pool
Active
$50,000
(August - Labor Day)
5Bd
3Ba
0.75Acr
2.8KSq Ft
Montauk
25 Glendale Dr
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$35,000
(September)
5Bd
5Ba
0.47Acr
3.5KSq Ft
Montauk
12 South Elroy Dr
Listing by Corcoran Group
Oceanview
Active
$46,000
(July)
5Bd
2+Ba
0.27Acr
2KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$98,000
(July)
5Bd
5Ba
1.2Acr
4.5KSq Ft
Montauk
66 Edison Dr
For Rent By Owner
Pool
Active
$10,500
(Short-Term)
5Bd
3.5Ba
0.21Acr
2.2KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by William Raveis Real Estate
South of highway
Active
$40,000
(September)
5Bd
3.5Ba
1.68Acr
2.8KSq Ft
Montauk
657 Old Montauk Hwy
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
Pool
Active
$70,000
(July)
5Bd
4.5Ba
0.93Acr
5KSq Ft
Montauk
30 Homeward Ln
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Oceanview
Active
$33,500
(August)
6Bd
5.5Ba
1Acr
5.5KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
Active
$30,000
(September)
5Bd
3.5Ba
0.4Acr
2.8KSq Ft
Montauk
67 North Farragut Rd
Listing by Martha Greene Real Estate llc
Active
$60,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
3.5Ba
0.83Acr
2.9KSq Ft
Montauk
50 Fairview Ave
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
Pool
Active
$230,000
(July - Labor Day)
6Bd
5.5Ba
5.7KSq Ft
Montauk
148 Tuthill Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$130,000
(July)
5Bd
6.5Ba
1Acr
4.95KSq Ft
Montauk
18 Big Reed Path
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
Active
$550,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
4Ba
1.69Acr
2.7KSq Ft
Montauk
380 Old Montauk Hwy
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
Attached garage
Active
$7,500
(Short-Term)
5Bd
3Ba
0.21Acr
Montauk
10 Prentice Pl
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$150,000
(July)
6Bd
7.5Ba
1.15Acr
6.16KSq Ft
Montauk
5 Agnew Ave
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
Active
$160,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
6.5Ba
Montauk
3 Royal Oak Way
For Rent By Owner
Active
$12,500
(Short-Term)
5Bd
4Ba
0.68Acr
1.9KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Nest Seekers International
Pool
Active
$38,000
(Short-Term)
5Bd
4.5Ba
3.8KSq Ft
Montauk
28 Washington Dr
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
Spa
Active
$20,000
(September)
5Bd
5Ba
0.37Acr
3.4KSq Ft
Montauk
5 South Dorset Dr
Listing by Compass
Pool
Active
$200,000
(Full Year)
7Bd
8Ba
0.39Acr
4.4KSq Ft
Montauk
137 Edgemere St
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
Spa
Active
$144,000
(Full Year)
5Bd
7.5Ba
0.57Acr
3KSq Ft
Montauk
131 Edgemere St
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
Pool
Active
$55,000
(September)
5Bd
4.5Ba
1Acr
4Sq Ft
Montauk
46 Edison Dr
For Rent By Owner
Pool
Active
$90,000
(July)
6Bd
4Ba
2Acr
3.6KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by SERHANT.
Pool
Active
$70,000
(September)
7Bd
6.5Ba
8.5KSq Ft
Montauk
10 Maple St
Listing by Marquis New York LLC
Garage
Active
$30,000
(July)
5Bd
2.5Ba
1.8KSq Ft
Montauk
18 Fairview Ave
Listing by William Raveis Real Estate
Pool
Active
$50,000
(Short-Term)
6Bd
5+Ba
0.65Acr
6.7KSq Ft
Montauk
63 Houston Dr
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Oceanview
Active
$45,000
(July)
5Bd
4Ba
0.15Acr
2.8KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Nest Seekers International
Active
$36,000
(July)
6Bd
3Ba
2.31KSq Ft
Montauk
113 Duryea Ave
Listing by Marquis New York LLC
Pool
Active
$30,000
(September)
6Bd
4.5Ba
0.48Acr
4.78KSq Ft
Montauk
38 Fairlawn Dr
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
Active
$110,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
3Ba
0.86Acr
4KSq Ft
Montauk
8 Big Reed Path
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$260,000
(July - Labor Day)
5Bd
6.5Ba
0.9Acr
3.7KSq Ft
Montauk
225 East Lake Dr
Listing by The Agency
South of highway
Active
$45,000
(August - Labor Day)
5Bd
2Ba
0.17Acr
1.7KSq Ft
Montauk
33 Hoppin Ave
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Garage
Active
$20,000
(July)
5Bd
2.5Ba
0.23Acr
1.8KSq Ft
Montauk
11 Tern Dr
Listing by William Raveis Real Estate
Pool
Active
$50,000
(September)
6Bd
5Ba
0.8Acr
4KSq Ft
Montauk
321 Old Montauk Hwy
Listing by Martha Greene Real Estate llc
Pool
Active
$200,000
(July)
5Bd
4+Ba
1.1Acr
5KSq Ft
Montauk
6 Beech St
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
Active
$85,000
(July)
5Bd
3Ba
1.5Acr
3KSq Ft
Montauk
351 East Lake Dr
Listing by Compass
Oceanview
Active
$85,000
(July)
5Bd
5Ba
3.5KSq Ft
Montauk
681 Old Montauk Hwy
Listing by Nest Seekers International
Spa
Active
$50,000
(August - Labor Day)
5Bd
2.5Ba
0.19Acr
2KSq Ft
Montauk
4 Prentice Pl
Listing by Nest Seekers International
Lakefront
Active
$75,000
(July)
5Bd
2.5Ba
0.25Acr
2.2KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Nest Seekers International

The Hamptons

North Fork

Quick Links

Sales
Rentals
Land
Browse All Homes
Stories
Guides
Open Houses
Careers
Press
Help

Zillow Group is committed to ensuring digital accessibility for individuals with disabilities. We are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone, and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests. If you wish to report an issue or seek an accommodation, please let us know.

© 2025 Out East

Dedication
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Contact Us