Shelter Island, NY Pets Allowed Homes For Rent

17 Results

56 North Cartwright Rd

Shelter Island

$70,000

(Memorial Day - Labor Day)

3 BD
1.5 BA
2 ACR
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
3 Lakeview Dr

Shelter Island

$40,000

(Memorial Day - Labor Day)

4 BD
2 BA
0.55 ACR
1.72K FT²
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
110 South Ferry Rd

Shelter Island

$70,000

(July - Labor Day)

3 BD
3 BA
0.92 ACR

Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
(Undisclosed Address)

Shelter Island

$18,000

(May)

3 BD
2 BA
0.75 ACR
1.65K FT²

Gunite Pool
For Rent By Owner
12 North Cartwright Rd

Shelter Island

$3,000

(March)

2 BD
1 BA
0.53 ACR
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
1 Gazon Rd

Shelter Island

$72,000

(Full Year)

4 BD
3 BA
0.5 ACR
2.6 FT²
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
32 Saint Marys Rd

Shelter Island

$58,000

(Memorial Day - Labor Day)

3 BD
2.5 BA
0.71 ACR

Gunite Pool
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
13 Brander Pkwy

Shelter Island

$8,000

(March)

5 BD
5.5 BA
0.08 ACR
3.87K FT²

Gunite Pool
Listing by Rove Travel
13 Dinah Rock Rd

Shelter Island

$70,000

(Memorial Day - Labor Day)

4 BD
3.5 BA
1.25 ACR
2.8K FT²
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
25 Smith St

Shelter Island

$4,500

(March)

4 BD
2 BA
1.5 ACR
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
5 Shorewood Rd

Shelter Island

$9,500

(September)

3 BD
2 BA
1 ACR
1.5K FT²
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
26 Winthrop Rd

Shelter Island

$3,500

(March)

5 BD
2 BA
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
(Undisclosed Address)

Shelter Island

$7,700

(June)

2 BD
2 BA
0.53 ACR
892 FT²
Listing by Saunders & Associates
13 North Brander Pkwy

Shelter Island

$12,000

(June)

3 BD
2 BA
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
(Undisclosed Address)

Shelter Island

$20,000

(Extended Season)

4 BD
2 BA
2.9 ACR
2.5K FT²

Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)

Shelter Island

$42,000

(July - Labor Day)

3 BD
2 BA
0.89 ACR
1.79K FT²

Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)

Shelter Island

$50,000

(Memorial Day - Labor Day)

4 BD
2.5 BA
1 ACR
2.45K FT²
Listing by Saunders & Associates