Skip to content
Menu
Rent
Buy
Stories
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Search
Rentals
The Hamptons
Water Mill
Water Mill, NY 5 Bedroom Homes For Rent
137 Results
9 Wheaton Way
Water Mill
$60,000
(May)
5
BD
5.5
BA
1.45
ACR
5.2K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by The Agency
70 Winding Way
Water Mill
$150,000
(June)
9
BD
8.5
BA
0.7
ACR
9K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
1 Diamon Ct
Water Mill
$250,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
6
BD
5+
BA
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
59 Mill Creek Close
Water Mill
$90,000
(August - Labor Day)
5
BD
4.5
BA
0.9
ACR
3.3K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Nest Seekers International
165 Cooks Ln
Water Mill
$1,500,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
9+
BA
2.5
ACR
20K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
video tour
1052, 988, & 986 Noyac Path
Water Mill
$425,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
7.5
BA
16
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
(Undisclosed Address)
Water Mill
$280,000
(April - Labor Day)
6
BD
4.5
BA
1.44
ACR
5.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Morley Real Estate
1264 Scuttle Hole Rd
Water Mill
$450,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
6
BD
8.5
BA
6.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
14 Swans Neck Ln
Water Mill
$250,000
(July - Labor Day)
6
BD
6
BA
1.05
ACR
5.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
958 Cobb Rd W
Water Mill
$115,000
(July)
6
BD
4
BA
1.13
ACR
6.7K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
904 Cobb Rd W
Water Mill
$600,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
6
BD
6+
BA
1.74
ACR
7.42K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
249 Roses Grove Rd
Water Mill
$155,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
6
BD
4.5
BA
3.8
ACR
3.55K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Christie's International Real Estate Group, LLC
108 Mill Creek Close
Water Mill
$65,000
(Short-Term)
5
BD
5.5
BA
0.89
ACR
6K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
385 Seven Ponds Towd Rd
Water Mill
$150,000
(June - July)
5
BD
5
BA
2.5
ACR
4.6K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
(Undisclosed Address)
Water Mill
$95,000
(July - Labor Day)
5
BD
4.5
BA
0.93
ACR
3.85K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by SERHANT.
325 Mecox Rd
Water Mill
$395,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
6+
BA
1.48
ACR
7.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
127 Head of Pond Rd
Water Mill
$100,000
(June)
7
BD
8+
BA
1.6
ACR
9K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
138 Montrose Ln
Water Mill
$250,000
(July)
6
BD
8+
BA
0.88
ACR
9.71K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
31 Mecox Bay Ln
Water Mill
$250,000
(June - July)
6
BD
6.5
BA
0.92
ACR
5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by The Agency
(Undisclosed Address)
Water Mill
$175,000
(August - Labor Day)
6
BD
6.5
BA
4.5
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Compass
80 Cobb Rd
Water Mill
$275,000
(July)
7
BD
7+
BA
1
ACR
9K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
102 Halsey Ln
Water Mill
$10,000
(March)
6
BD
6+
BA
0.44
ACR
4.73K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by The Agency
185 Upper 7 Ponds Rd
Water Mill
$275,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
5
BD
2.5
BA
0.35
ACR
2.15K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
1476 Scuttle Hole Rd
Water Mill
$89,000
(July - Labor Day)
5
BD
3
BA
1
ACR
3K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
1050 Head Of Pond Rd
Water Mill
$100,000
(August - Labor Day)
5
BD
5.5
BA
0.84
ACR
4K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
180 Rose Hill Rd
Water Mill
$350,000
(June)
12
BD
10+
BA
2.75
ACR
16K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
44 Little Noyac Path
Water Mill
$200,000
(July)
6
BD
5+
BA
1.7
ACR
8K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
video tour
1150 Scuttle Hole Rd
Water Mill
$600,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
8+
BA
1.33
ACR
11.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
1144 Noyac Path
Water Mill
$70,000
(May)
7
BD
8.5
BA
3
ACR
8K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
178 Bay Ln
Water Mill
$100,000
(March)
7
BD
9+
BA
2
ACR
13K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
(Undisclosed Address)
Water Mill
$7,000
(April)
5
BD
4.5
BA
3
ACR
4.5K
FT
2
Pool
For Rent By Owner
56 Pauls Ln
Water Mill
$275,000
(August - Labor Day)
7
BD
8+
BA
2.3
ACR
7.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
244 Little Noyac Path
Water Mill
$45,000
(May)
8
BD
7.5
BA
2.73
ACR
7.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
21 Old Country Rd
Water Mill
$250,000
(August - Labor Day)
7
BD
8+
BA
1.61
ACR
Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
449 Blank Ln
Water Mill
$425,000
(July - Labor Day)
7
BD
6.5
BA
1.2
ACR
9K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
170 Pauls Ln
Water Mill
$40,000
(Short-Term)
5
BD
7+
BA
1.1
ACR
6.4K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
17 Jordan Dr
Water Mill
$11,000
(March)
5
BD
3+
BA
1.25
ACR
3.9K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
83 Pauls Ln
Water Mill
$45,000
(June)
5
BD
4+
BA
0.92
ACR
2.61K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by The Agency
video tour
9 Schwenks Rd
Water Mill
$150,000
(June)
6
BD
7.5
BA
0.9
ACR
6.82K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
29 Wood Edge Ct
Water Mill
$50,000
(April)
7
BD
7.5
BA
1.88
ACR
6.43K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
(Undisclosed Address)
Water Mill
$600,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
10
BA
3.75
ACR
10K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
392 Seven Ponds Towd Rd
Water Mill
$650,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
9+
BA
1.4
ACR
11.1K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
394 Seven Ponds Towd Rd
Water Mill
$650,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
8
BD
9+
BA
1.4
ACR
12.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
137 Mill Creek Close
Water Mill
$40,000
(June)
8
BD
7.5
BA
0.88
ACR
6.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
(Undisclosed Address)
Water Mill
$30,000
(June)
5
BD
4
BA
0.92
ACR
3.2K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
507 Mecox Rd
Water Mill
$55,000
(August - Labor Day)
5
BD
4
BA
0.98
ACR
5.18K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
451 Scuttle Hole Rd
Water Mill
$200,000
(August - Labor Day)
5
BD
4.5
BA
1.94
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
217 Water Mill Towd Rd
Water Mill
$7,500
(March)
6
BD
5
BA
0.67
ACR
4.65K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Marquis New York LLC
23 Stephen Halsey Path
Water Mill
$250,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
5
BD
6.5
BA
0.93
ACR
3.06K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
24 Deer Run
Water Mill
$350,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
6
BD
6+
BA
1
ACR
84K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
