Sign In

Real Estate in Shelter Island

122 Results
New
46770
Shelter Island
$5,545,000
4 BD
5 BA
1.5 ACR
4.78K SQ FT
WATERFRONT
Save
129702
Shelter Island
$3,995,000
5 BD
5 BA
3.3 ACR
5.5K SQ FT
Save
27301
Shelter Island
$975,000
3 BD
2 BA
0.7 ACR
2.15K SQ FT
Save
27299
Shelter Island
$2,995,000
3 BD
2 BA
1.3 ACR
2.09K SQ FT
WATERFRONT
Save
43793
Shelter Island
$4,895,000
5 BD
5 BA
1.1 ACR
5.2K SQ FT
WATERFRONT
Save
46551
Shelter Island
$1,350,000
4 BD
2 BA
0.5 ACR
1.52K SQ FT
Save
57950
Shelter Island
$975,000
3 BD
2 BA
0.7 ACR
2K SQ FT
Save
132977
Shelter Island
$1,795,000
4 BD
3 BA
0.9 ACR
3K SQ FT
Save
46757
Shelter Island
$6,950,000
7 BD
8 BA
1.9 ACR
7.17K SQ FT
WATERFRONT
Save
123545
Shelter Island
$1,895,000
5 BD
5 BA
0.8 ACR
4.7K SQ FT
Save
132954
Shelter Island
$4,395,000
5 BD
5 BA
2.1 ACR
4.67K SQ FT
WATERFRONT
Save
46320
Shelter Island
$5,995,000
4 BD
4 BA
2.3 ACR
4.3K SQ FT
WATERFRONT
Save
The Hamptons
Amagansett
Sales Rentals
Bridgehampton
Sales Rentals
East Hampton
Sales Rentals
East Quogue
Sales Rentals
Hampton Bays
Sales Rentals
Montauk
Sales Rentals
North Sea
Sales Rentals
Quiogue
Sales Rentals
Quogue
Sales Rentals
Remsenburg
Sales Rentals
Sag Harbor
Sales Rentals
Sagaponack
Sales Rentals
Shelter Island
Sales Rentals
Shinnecock Hills
Sales Rentals
Southampton
Sales Rentals
Wainscott
Sales Rentals
Water Mill
Sales Rentals
Westhampton
Sales Rentals
Westhampton Beach
Sales Rentals
West Hampton Dunes
Sales Rentals
Center Moriches
Sales Rentals
Eastport
Sales Rentals
East Moriches
Sales Rentals
Flanders
Sales Rentals
Moriches
Sales Rentals
Shelter Island Heights
Sales Rentals
Speonk
Sales Rentals
Noyack
Sales Rentals
North Fork
Aquebogue
Sales Rentals
Baiting Hollow
Sales Rentals
Calverton
Sales Rentals
Cutchogue
Sales Rentals
East Marion
Sales Rentals
Greenport
Sales Rentals
Jamesport
Sales Rentals
Laurel
Sales Rentals
Mattituck
Sales Rentals
Nassau Point
Sales Rentals
New Suffolk
Sales Rentals
Orient
Sales Rentals
Peconic
Sales Rentals
Riverhead
Sales Rentals
South Jamesport
Sales Rentals
Southold
Sales Rentals
Manorville
Sales Rentals
Brookhaven
Sales Rentals
Northville
Sales Rentals
Wading River
Sales Rentals
Quick Links
Sales Rentals Land Guides Careers
Select Photography by Jake Rajs
Select Photography by Jake Rajs
© 2018 Out East Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Contact Us
Zillow Trulia StreetEasy HotPads
Naked Apartments RealEstate.com