Skip to content
Menu
Rent
Buy
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Stories
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Sales
The Hamptons
Shelter Island
Shelter Island, NY Real Estate & Homes For Sale
48 Results
New
Pool
For Sale
$3,850,000
4
Bd
5
Ba
1.41
Acr
3.99K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
8 Hilo Dr
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
For Sale
$3,300,000
6
Bd
4
Ba
0.9
Acr
4.54K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
126 South Midway Rd
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
Pool
For Sale
$2,675,000
4
Bd
3
Ba
1.4
Acr
Shelter Island
55 Peconic Ave
Listing by SERHANT.
For Sale
$4,479,000
4
Bd
4
Ba
0.5
Acr
3K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
70 Peconic Ave
Listing by SERHANT.
Pool
For Sale
$2,895,000
4
Bd
2
Ba
1.8
Acr
1.83K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
4 Sheep Pasture Ln
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
For Sale
$5,500,000
4
Bd
5
Ba
2
Acr
4K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
11 Sunnyside Ave
Listing by Compass
Pool
For Sale
$3,600,000
4
Bd
2
Ba
2
Acr
2.89K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
24 Rocky Point Rd
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
For Sale
$1,950,000
5
Bd
3
Ba
1.3
Acr
Shelter Island
70 South Ferry Rd
Listing by SERHANT.
Pool
For Sale
$3,500,000
5
Bd
4
Ba
0.96
Acr
3.5K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
16 Osprey Rd
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
For Sale
$4,250,000
4
Bd
5
Ba
4.4K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
141A North Ferry Rd
Listing by Atlas Sales Realty LLC
For Sale
$1,895,000
4
Bd
3
Ba
0.88
Acr
2.3K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
73 North Midway Rd
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Pool
For Sale
$995,000
3
Bd
3
Ba
0.43
Acr
1.92K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
65 North Midway Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
For Sale
$695,000
1
Acr
Shelter Island
1 Strawberry Ln
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
Pool
For Sale
$2,999,000
3
Bd
2
Ba
1.08
Acr
1.37K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
13 Tarkettle Rd
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Creek/inletfront
For Sale
$1,300,000
2
Bd
2
Ba
0.12
Acr
1.32K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
1 Meadow St
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
For Sale
$1,789,000
3
Bd
2
Ba
2.25
Acr
1.5K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
21 Lakeview Dr
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
For Sale
$5,350,000
4
Bd
4
Ba
0.51
Acr
2.94K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
29 East Brander Pkwy
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Spa
For Sale
$1,695,000
4
Bd
3
Ba
1.47
Acr
1.7K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
26 S Menantic Rd
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Garage
For Sale
$1,195,000
3
Bd
2
Ba
0.58
Acr
1.34K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
10 Strawberry Ln
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Pool
For Sale
$4,250,000
4
Bd
5
Ba
0.46
Acr
3.68K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
8 Cove Way
Listing by Saunders & Associates
For Sale
$1,850,000
4
Bd
2
Ba
0.19
Acr
2.01K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
7 Locust Ave & 4 Meadow Pl
Listing by Saunders & Associates
For Sale
$3,750,000
4
Bd
3
Ba
0.88
Acr
2.2K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
52 South Midway Rd
Listing by The Agency
Pondfront
For Sale
$1,395,000
4
Bd
2
Ba
1.12
Acr
2.13K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
15 Congdon Rd
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
For Sale
$5,150,000
5
Bd
4
Ba
2.94
Acr
3.16K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
5 North Menantic Rd
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
For Sale
$2,500,000
3
Bd
4
Ba
1.8
Acr
2.18K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
69 Saint Marys Rd
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
For Sale
$4,445,000
6
Bd
6
Ba
2.16
Acr
Shelter Island
100 South Ferry Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
For Sale
$1,875,000
3
Bd
2
Ba
1.2
Acr
3.04K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
7 Fox Hollow Rd
Listing by Saunders & Associates
Pool
For Sale
$10,750,000
6
Bd
6
Ba
1
Acr
4.2K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
37 East Brander Pkwy
Listing by Corcoran Group
Garage
For Sale
$1,295,000
3
Bd
2
Ba
0.5
Acr
2.06K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
9 Worthy Way
Listing by Corcoran Group
Pool
For Sale
$4,900,000
3
Bd
3
Ba
0.74
Acr
2.06K
Sq Ft
Shelter Island
68 Peconic Ave
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
