1 / 38

1-3 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$4,750,000

Beds

3
Baths

2
Acres

1.32
Sq. ft.

1,851 1.85K

Listing by Saunders & Associates (9 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights NY 11965)

Last Verified:

Jul 28, 2026

Highlights

CLASSIC SHELTER ISLAND WATERFRONT BEACH COTTAGE

On the south side of Shelter Island, this classic waterfront beach cottage is set on 1.3 acres with approximately 375+/- feet of sandy shoreline. Approaching the house, salt breezes drift through thoughtfully designed meditation and outdoor dining areas tucked beneath hardy cedar trees. Nearby, a pair of Adirondack chairs beside a kayak invite quiet mornings on the water or an afternoon paddle along the shoreline. Built in 1940, the cottage re

Home Details

Construction

Property type: Single-family

Property style: Beach-cottage

New construction: No

Year built: 1940

Interior Details

Sq. ft: 1,851

Price per square foot: $2,566/sqft

Basement type: Partial

Stories: 1

Floors: Hardwood

Fireplaces: 1

Bedrooms & Bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3

Full bathrooms: 2

Bathroom on first floor: Yes

Primary bedroom on first floor: Yes

Other Rooms

Office

Utilities

Water source: Well

Central air conditioning: Yes

Financial Details

Price: $4,750,000

Taxes: $14,280/yr

Outdoor Details

Pool & Spa

Pool: No

Room for a pool: No

Parking

Garage: Yes

Spaces in garage: 1

Outdoor Amenities

Tennis: No

Room for a tennis court: No

Water frontage/View: None / mainland

Outdoor Shower(s): No

Rights & Access

Water access: Yes

Beach rights: Yes

Lot Details

Lot size: 1.32 Acres

South of highway: No

Location

Nearby Beaches
- 1 mile
  Shell Beach
- 1 mile
  Wades Beach
- 2 miles
  Crescent Beach
Nearby Transportation
- 2 miles
  Shelter Island - Shelter Island Seaplane Base
- 3 miles
  Greenport - LIRR
- 4 miles
  Greenport - Hampton Jitney

View on google maps

Listing info

1-3 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island

$4,750,000

You might also like