Skip to content
Menu
Rent
Buy
Stories
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Search
Sales
The Hamptons
Shelter Island
Shelter Island, NY 2 Bedroom Homes For Sale
44 Results
31 Grand Ave
Shelter Island
$3,200,000
6
BD
4.5
BA
0.37
ACR
2.64K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$6,750,000
5
BD
3.5
BA
1.5
ACR
4.05K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
30 Brander Pkwy
Shelter Island
$1,795,000
3
BD
3
BA
0.75
ACR
1.93K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
79 North Midway Rd
Shelter Island
$8,750,000
8
BD
6+
BA
7
ACR
8K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
11 Petticoat Ln #F
Shelter Island
$1,395,000
4
BD
2
BA
0.92
ACR
1.9K
FT
2
Listing by Corcoran Group
62 Country Club Dr
Shelter Island
$1,495,000
2
BD
2
BA
1.2
ACR
2.16K
FT
2
Listing by Corcoran Group
90 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island
$5,700,000
5
BD
3.5
BA
1
ACR
3.33K
FT
2
Listing by Susan C Cincotta Real Estate Broker LLC
20 Bowditch Rd
Shelter Island
$1,195,000
4
BD
2.5
BA
0.7
ACR
1.83K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
5 Brander Pkwy
Shelter Island
$1,645,000
3
BD
2
BA
1.04
ACR
1.44K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
10 Sunshine Rd #B
Shelter Island
$2,795,000
4
BD
4.5
BA
0.92
ACR
5.3K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
5 Bay Shore Rd
Shelter Island
$2,990,000
3
BD
2
BA
0.53
ACR
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
video tour
70 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island
$5,850,000
4
BD
4.5
BA
0.5
ACR
2.97K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Saunders & Associates
7 Grand Ave
Shelter Island
$1,625,000
4
BD
2.5
BA
0.24
ACR
2.1K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
1 Gazon Rd
Shelter Island
$1,699,999
4
BD
3
BA
0.5
ACR
2.62K
FT
2
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
8 Hilo Dr
Shelter Island
$3,950,000
4
BD
5.5
BA
1.41
ACR
3.9K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
video tour
23C West Neck Rd
Shelter Island
$1,995,000
3
BD
2.5
BA
1
ACR
2.96K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
video tour
8 Cove Way
Shelter Island
$5,750,000
4
BD
5
BA
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
video tour
5 Washington St
Shelter Island
$1,295,000
5
BD
2.5
BA
0.18
ACR
1.97K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
15 Dickerson Dr
Shelter Island
$2,895,000
3
BD
3
BA
1
ACR
1.87K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Saunders & Associates
52 South Midway Rd
Shelter Island
$3,595,000
4
BD
3
BA
0.88
ACR
2.2K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Corcoran Group
1 Pandion Rd
Shelter Island
$14,950,000
6
BD
6+
BA
3.4
ACR
6K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
5 Hagar Rd
Shelter Island
$2,399,000
3
BD
2.5
BA
0.46
ACR
3.31K
FT
2
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
11 Sunnyside Ave
Shelter Island
$5,500,000
4
BD
4.5
BA
2
ACR
4K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Compass
video tour
1 Valley Rd
Shelter Island
$2,350,000
4
BD
3.5
BA
0.7
ACR
2.2K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
video tour
21 Congdon Rd
Shelter Island
$2,175,000
3
BD
2.5
BA
2.24
ACR
2.32K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
video tour
24 Rocky Point Rd
Shelter Island
$3,600,000
4
BD
3.5
BA
2
ACR
3K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
video tour
179 Ram Island Dr
Shelter Island
$5,750,000
6
BD
7.5
BA
2.2
ACR
Waterfront
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$1,950,000
5
BD
3
BA
1.13
ACR
2K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Compass
106 South Ferry Rd
Shelter Island
$2,695,000
4
BD
4
BA
3.25
ACR
2.42K
FT
2
Listing by Corcoran Group
9 Crescent Way
Shelter Island
$1,895,000
3
BD
2.5
BA
0.96
ACR
2.37K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
video tour
8 Little Ram Island Dr
Shelter Island
$12,750,000
8
BD
9.5
BA
2.2
ACR
8.5K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Sotheby's International Realty
65 North Midway Rd
Shelter Island
$1,195,000
3
BD
3
BA
0.43
ACR
1.72K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
4 Irene Ln
Shelter Island
$2,390,000
4
BD
3
BA
0.68
ACR
2.03K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
47B S Ferry Rd
Shelter Island
$3,995,000
3
BD
2
BA
1.74
ACR
1.8K
FT
2
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
55 Shore Rd
Shelter Island
$7,950,000
5
BD
5.5
BA
1.26
ACR
7.5K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Bespoke Real Estate
47L S Ferry Rd
Shelter Island
$9,900,000
4
BD
3.5
BA
0.91
ACR
3.8K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
8 Tims Trl
Shelter Island
$1,799,000
4
BD
4.5
BA
0.62
ACR
3.69K
FT
2
For Sale By Owner
video tour
34 North Cartwright Rd #A
Shelter Island
$17,975,000
5
BD
5
BA
2.1
ACR
5.45K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Saunders & Associates
video tour
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$2,050,000
3
BD
2
BA
1.05
ACR
3.17K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
20 Prospect Ave
Shelter Island
$4,995,000
7
BD
6
BA
1.2
ACR
5K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
6-6A South Ram Island Dr
Shelter Island
$5,445,000
3
BD
2
BA
1.75
ACR
1.62K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
video tour
33 West Neck Rd
Shelter Island
$1,050,000
2
BD
2
BA
0.28
ACR
1.27K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
28 Smith St
Shelter Island
$1,350,000
3
BD
2
BA
0.34
ACR
1.42K
FT
2
Listing by Simon Harrison Real Estate
4 Duvall Rd
Shelter Island
$1,350,000
2
BD
2
BA
0.5
ACR
1.2K
FT
2
Listing by Simon Harrison Real Estate
