1 / 38

23 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

November 2025$5,000
December 2025$5,000
Short-Term 2025 $65,000

Beds

3
Baths

3
Acres
Sq. ft.

Listing by Marquis New York LLC (860 Montauk Highway, Water Mill NY 11976)

Last Verified:

Nov 20, 2025

Highlights

Chic Coastal Farmhouse with Private Pool, Steps from the Water

Inquire to book this property directly here: staymarquis.com/properties/ram-island-beauty/otes-682cc968d7b00

Tucked away on a peaceful, tree-lined street in the heart of Shelter Island, this newly renovated beach-cottage-style farmhouse offers an idyllic escape where timeless charm meets modern luxury. Just moments from the water’s edge, this coastal haven is steps from the tranquil shores of Coecles Harbor, offering partial water view

Home Details

Construction

Property type: Single-family

New construction: No

Interior Details

Sq. ft: -

Furnished: Yes

Bedrooms & Bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3

Full bathrooms: 3

Bathroom on first floor: Yes

Primary bedroom on first floor: Yes

Linens: Yes

Utilities

Central air conditioning: Yes

Tv/cable/satellite: Yes

House Rules

Pet policy: Pets considered

Smoking policy: Not allowed

Outdoor Details

Pool & Spa

Pool: Yes

Heated pool: Yes

Parking

Garage: Yes

Spaces in garage: 1

Outdoor Amenities

Tennis: No

Room for a tennis court: No

Water frontage/View: None / mainland

Outdoor Shower(s): No

Lot Details

Near jitney sunrise bus line: Yes

Near train station: Yes

South of highway: No

Location

Nearby Beaches
- 3 miles
  Wades Beach
- 4 miles
  Shell Beach
- 4 miles
  Orient Beach State Park
Nearby Transportation
- 4 miles
  Shelter Island - Shelter Island Seaplane Base
- 4 miles
  Greenport - Hampton Jitney
- 4 miles
  Greenport - LIRR

View on google maps

Listing info

You might also like