Shelter Island, NY Vacation & Summer Rentals | Out East

Shelter Island, NY Vacation & Summer Rentals

41 Results

Pool
Active
$20,000
(September)
4Bd
2Ba
1.5Acr
2.49KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Compass
Pool
Active
$30,000
(November)
6Bd
3Ba
1.01Acr
2.4KSq Ft
Shelter Island
4 North Silver Beach Rd
For Rent By Owner
Bayfront
Active
$80,000
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
1Acr
1.8KSq Ft
Shelter Island
3 Bevan Pl
Listing by The Agency
Pool
Active
$25,000
(September)
4Bd
4Ba
Shelter Island
23 Tuthill Dr
Listing by Compass
Pool
Active
$55,000
(July)
4Bd
3Ba
6.8Acr
3KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by Compass
Pondfront
Active
$20,000
(Short-Term)
4Bd
3Ba
1.07Acr
3.48KSq Ft
Shelter Island
23 Osprey Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$30,000
(October)
5Bd
3Ba
2.01Acr
1.7KSq Ft
Shelter Island
19 Bay Shore Dr
For Rent By Owner
Garage
Active
$25,000
(September)
4Bd
4Ba
0.84Acr
4.59KSq Ft
Shelter Island
22 Dinah Rock Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Active
$5,500
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
1Acr
1.5KSq Ft
Shelter Island
18 Hay Beach Rd
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
Pool
Active
$7,000
(Short-Term)
3Bd
2Ba
1.01Acr
1.47KSq Ft
Shelter Island
47 North Midway Rd
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$12,000
(September)
4Bd
3Ba
0.5Acr
2.62KSq Ft
Shelter Island
4 Glynn Dr
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$20,000
(Short-Term)
4Bd
3Ba
0.92Acr
3.32KSq Ft
Shelter Island
3 Primrose Pl
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$12,000
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
Shelter Island
7 Marc St
Listing by Marquis New York LLC
Pool
Active
$25,000
(September)
4Bd
2Ba
0.75Acr
2.4KSq Ft
Shelter Island
41 Menantic Rd
For Rent By Owner
Active
$9,300
(November)
4Bd
2Ba
Shelter Island
12 Dogwood Ln
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Waterfront
Active
$14,000
(Short-Term)
4Bd
2Ba
Shelter Island
80 Peconic Ave
Listing by SERHANT.
Attached garage
Active
$10,000
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
2.1KSq Ft
Shelter Island
16 Glynn Dr
Listing by Rove Travel
Garage
Active
$3,900
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
0.89Acr
1.49KSq Ft
Shelter Island
4 Ivy Pl
Listing by Corcoran Group
Bayview
Active
$140,000
(Full Year)
4Bd
3Ba
1.5Acr
3.1KSq Ft
Shelter Island
36 Gardiners Bay Dr
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
Pool
Active
$10,000
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
1Acr
2.32KSq Ft
Shelter Island
4 Great Circle Dr
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$11,000
(Short-Term)
3Bd
2Ba
0.89Acr
1.38KSq Ft
Shelter Island
21 Lake Dr
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Creek/inletfront
Active
$10,000
(September)
4Bd
4Ba
Shelter Island
24 South Midway Rd
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
Pool
Active
$14,000
(Short-Term)
4Bd
2Ba
1.6KSq Ft
Shelter Island
5 Mimosa Pl
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Garage
Active
$4,000
(Short-Term)
4Bd
2Ba
Shelter Island
11 Prospect Ave
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Pool
Active
$5,500
(October)
2Bd
2Ba
1.2Acr
1.6KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
For Rent By Owner
Waterfront
Active
$90,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
3Bd
3Ba
Shelter Island
2 East Brander Pkwy
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
Active
$4,000
(Short-Term)
2Bd
1Ba
1.5Acr
700Sq Ft
Shelter Island
2 Prospect Ave
For Rent By Owner
Pool
Active
$15,000
(September)
3Bd
2Ba
0.75Acr
1.65KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
For Rent By Owner
Pool
Active
$20,000
(Short-Term)
5Bd
3Ba
Shelter Island
70 South Ferry Rd
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
Pool
Active
$15,000
(Short-Term)
5Bd
5Ba
2.9Acr
4.3KSq Ft
(Undisclosed Address)
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.