1 / 29

23 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

July 2026$40,000
August - Labor Day 2026 $55,000
August 2026$50,000

Beds

3
Baths

3
Acres
Sq. ft.

Listing by Compass (2424 Main Street, Bridgehampton NY 11932)

Last Verified:

Jul 13, 2026

Highlights

Shelter Island Serenity And A True Luxury Summer Hideaway

Nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, Shelter Island offers a peaceful, upscale alternative to the bustling Hamptons. While also providing easy and convenient access to all they have to offer.
This boutique property is an intimate and sophisticated home that melds contemporary art with curated high-end finishes. The sparkling heated pool is central to the luxurious interior and exterior living space from the priv

Home Details

Construction

Property type: Single-family

Property style: Beach-cottage

New construction: No

Interior Details

Sq. ft: -

Stories: 1

Fireplaces: 1

Furnished: Yes

Bedrooms & Bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3

Full bathrooms: 3

Bathroom on first floor: Yes

Primary bedroom on first floor: Yes

Linens: Yes

Other Rooms

Breakfast area, Great room, Laundry room

Utilities

Central air conditioning: Yes

Tv/cable/satellite: Yes

House Rules

Pet policy: Pets considered

Smoking policy: Not allowed

Outdoor Details

Pool & Spa

Pool: Yes

Heated pool: Yes

Pool material: Gunite

Parking

Garage: No

Outdoor Amenities

Tennis: No

Room for a tennis court: No

Water frontage/View: Waterview

Outdoor Shower(s): No

Rights & Access

Water access: Yes

Beach rights: Yes

Lot Details

South of highway: No

Location

Nearby Beaches
- 3 miles
  Wades Beach
- 4 miles
  Shell Beach
- 4 miles
  Orient Beach State Park
Nearby Transportation
- 4 miles
  Shelter Island - Shelter Island Seaplane Base
- 4 miles
  Greenport - Hampton Jitney
- 4 miles
  Greenport - LIRR

View on google maps

Listing info

You might also like