72 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Memorial Day - Labor Day 2026 $145,000
- July - Labor Day 2026 $125,000
- July 2026$55,000
-
Beds
4
-
Baths
4.5
-
Acres
1
-
Sq. ft.
Last Verified:
Dec 12, 2025
Highlights
HAY BEACH WATERFRONT WITH SANDY BEACH AND POOL
Rarely does a palatial waterfront home with sandy beach become available for a full summer rental. This pristine home has four ensuite bedrooms, vaulted living room ceiling, wood burning fireplace, chef's eat in kitchen, finished lower level with walkout and water views. The outdoors features a waterside swimming pool with spacious decks and a screen in porch. Plus, a gorgeous sugar sandy beach. Asking: $145K for May 22, to Sept 7, 2026. July
Home Details
Construction
Property type: Single-family
Property style: Contemporary
New construction: No
Interior Details
Sq. ft: 5,500
Basement type: Full
Finished basement: Yes
Stories: 3
Fireplaces: 2
Furnished: Yes
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
Bedrooms: 4
Full bathrooms: 4
Half bathrooms: 1
Bathroom on first floor: Yes
Primary bedroom on first floor: Yes
Linens: Yes
Other Rooms
Bonus room, Breakfast area, Laundry room, Library, Office
Utilities
Water source: Well
Heat type: Gas hot air
Central air conditioning: Yes
Tv/cable/satellite: Yes
House Rules
Pet policy: Pets considered
Smoking policy: Not allowed
Outdoor Details
Pool & Spa
Pool: Yes
Heated pool: Yes
Pool material: Gunite
Parking
Garage: Yes
Spaces in garage: 2
Outdoor Amenities
Tennis: No
Room for a tennis court: No
Water frontage/View: Bayfront
Outdoor Shower(s): No
Rights & Access
Water access: Yes
Beach rights: Yes
Lot Details
Lot size: 1.0 Acres
Lot with trees: Yes
South of highway: No
Community Amenities
Clubhouse/recreation, Community tennis, Golf course
Location
-
Nearby Transportation
-
2 milesEast Marion - Hampton Jitney
-
2 milesGreenport - Hampton Jitney
-
2 milesGreenport - LIRR
-
-
Nearby Beaches
-
3 milesTruman's Beach
-
3 milesCrescent Beach
-
4 milesOrient Beach State Park
-
