Skip to content
Menu
Rent
Buy
Stories
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Saved Items
Submit Your Listing
For Sale by Owner
For Rent by Owner
Sign In
Sign Up
Search
Rentals
The Hamptons
Shelter Island
Shelter Island, NY Single Family Homes For Rent
84 Results
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$42,000
(August - Labor Day)
4
BD
4
BA
0.97
ACR
2.42K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$20,000
(July)
4
BD
3
BA
0.92
ACR
3.19K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$30,000
(June)
3
BD
2.5
BA
0.74
ACR
2.06K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$4,000
(March)
3
BD
2.5
BA
0.68
ACR
1.98K
FT
2
For Rent By Owner
61 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island
$175,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
5
BD
5.5
BA
0.69
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
56 North Cartwright Rd
Shelter Island
$70,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
3
BD
1.5
BA
2
ACR
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$25,000
(July)
8
BD
3
BA
0.94
ACR
2.72K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
34 Country Club Dr
Shelter Island
$45,000
(July)
4
BD
5.5
BA
0.9
ACR
4K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
45 New York Ave
Shelter Island
$65,000
(June - July)
4
BD
2+
BA
Listing by Brown Harris Stevens
2 East Brander Pkwy
Shelter Island
$65,000
(June - July)
3
BD
3
BA
0.45
ACR
2.29K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
63 Menantic Rd
Shelter Island
$25,000
(June)
3
BD
3
BA
1.3
ACR
2.21K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
103 South Midway Rd
Shelter Island
$5,000
(March)
3
BD
2.5
BA
Tennis
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
1 Pandion Rd
Shelter Island
$475,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
6
BD
6+
BA
3.4
ACR
6K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$25,000
(Short-Term)
3
BD
3
BA
1
ACR
2.89K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$9,000
(June)
1
BD
1
BA
0.62
ACR
1.33K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$31,000
(October)
5
BD
3.5
BA
1.01
ACR
2.55K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$15,000
(August - Labor Day)
4
BD
2.5
BA
0.9
ACR
2.05K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
23 Tuthill Dr
Shelter Island
$10,000
(April)
3
BD
3
BA
Gunite Pool
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
32 Hilo Dr
Shelter Island
$69,000
(August - Labor Day)
4
BD
4.5
BA
1
ACR
2.24K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Corcoran Group
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$15,000
(June)
5
BD
4
BA
0.52
ACR
3.13K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$69,000
(July)
4
BD
4.5
BA
0.91
ACR
5.12K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$45,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
3
BD
2
BA
1.5
ACR
1.6K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Saunders & Associates
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$55,000
(July - Labor Day)
5
BD
4.5
BA
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$25,000
(June)
4
BD
3.5
BA
6.8
ACR
1.73K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$100,000
(July)
3
BD
3.5
BA
2.22
ACR
3.03K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$65,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
4
BD
4.5
BA
0.92
ACR
2.45K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$45,000
(August - Labor Day)
4
BD
4.5
BA
1.8
ACR
3.71K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
3 Lakeview Dr
Shelter Island
$40,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
4
BD
2
BA
0.55
ACR
1.72K
FT
2
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
11 Dickerson Dr
Shelter Island
$7,500
(March)
4
BD
4.5
BA
1.3
ACR
3K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
5 Bay Ave
Shelter Island
$84,000
(Full Year)
3
BD
3
BA
0.58
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
8 Petticoat Ln
Shelter Island
$7,500
(June)
3
BD
2.5
BA
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
110 South Ferry Rd
Shelter Island
$70,000
(July - Labor Day)
3
BD
3
BA
0.92
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
104 South Ferry Rd
Shelter Island
$150,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
5
BD
5.5
BA
3.44
ACR
4.04K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$13,000
(Short-Term)
4
BD
2
BA
0.54
ACR
1.76K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by Saunders & Associates
26 Ole Buck Run
Shelter Island
$3,500
(May)
3
BD
2
BA
0.89
ACR
1.24K
FT
2
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
20 Merkel Ln
Shelter Island
$12,000
(April)
2
BD
2
BA
Waterfront
For Rent By Owner
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$18,000
(May)
3
BD
2
BA
0.75
ACR
1.65K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
For Rent By Owner
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$55,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
3
BD
2.5
BA
0.68
ACR
2.43K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
5 Montclair Ave
Shelter Island
$45,000
(August - Labor Day)
3
BD
1.5
BA
0.5
ACR
1.23K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
70 South Ferry Rd
Shelter Island
$4,000
(March)
5
BD
3
BA
1.13
ACR
2K
FT
2
Pool
Listing by Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
6 Cobbetts Ln
Shelter Island
$15,000
(Short-Term)
5
BD
4
BA
Gunite Pool
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$120,000
(August - Labor Day)
6
BD
4.5
BA
2
ACR
4.24K
FT
2
Waterfront
Listing by M Wein Realty Inc.
12 North Cartwright Rd
Shelter Island
$3,000
(March)
2
BD
1
BA
0.53
ACR
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
31 Saint Marys Rd
Shelter Island
$50,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
2
BD
1.5
BA
0.62
ACR
1.2K
FT
2
Listing by The Agency
1 Gazon Rd
Shelter Island
$72,000
(Full Year)
4
BD
3
BA
0.5
ACR
Listing by Griffing & Collins Real Estate
32 Saint Marys Rd
Shelter Island
$58,000
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
3
BD
2.5
BA
0.71
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate
8 Burns Rd
Shelter Island
$6,500
(March)
3
BD
3
BA
0.32
ACR
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
28 Gardiners Bay Dr
Shelter Island
$95,000
(July - Labor Day)
3
BD
3
BA
1.87
ACR
Gunite Pool
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
13 Brander Pkwy
Shelter Island
$8,000
(March)
5
BD
5.5
BA
0.08
ACR
3.87K
FT
2
Gunite Pool
Listing by Rove Travel
(Undisclosed Address)
Shelter Island
$40,750
(Memorial Day - Labor Day)
4
BD
1.5
BA
0.5
ACR
1.46K
FT
2
Listing by Saunders & Associates
