5 North Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
-
Beds
5
-
Baths
4.5
-
Acres
2.94
-
Sq. ft.
Last Verified:
Nov 20, 2025
Highlights
ICONIC WATERFRONT ESTATE
A rare offering on Shelter Island, this waterfront estate represents a legacy of architectural pedigree and enduring luxury. Built in 1860 and renovated over the years, the home is a singular blend of history and Hamptons elegance, set on nearly 3 acres with western-facing water views, a deepwater dock, and every hallmark of refined coastal living. In an iconic Shelter Island location on West Neck Creek, this timeless model of Federal-style a
Home Details
Construction
Property type: Single-family
Property style: Federal
New construction: No
Year built: 1860
Interior Details
Sq. ft: 3,157
Price per square foot: $1,631/sqft
Basement type: Full
Stories: 2
Floors: Hardwood, Tile
Fireplaces: 3
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
Bedrooms: 5
Full bathrooms: 4
Half bathrooms: 1
Bathroom on first floor: Yes
Primary bedroom on first floor: Yes
Other Rooms
Bonus room, Family room/den, Great room, In-law suite/private guest quarters, Laundry room, Library, Office, Studio, Study
Utilities
Heat type: Gas hot air
Central air conditioning: Yes
Financial Details
Price: $5,150,000
Taxes: $26,438/yr
Outdoor Details
Pool & Spa
Pool: Yes
Pool material: Gunite
Parking
Garage: Yes
Attached garage: Yes
Spaces in garage: 2
Outdoor Amenities
Tennis: No
Room for a tennis court: No
Water frontage/View: Waterfront
Outdoor Shower(s): Yes
Sprinkler system: Yes
Dock: Yes
Rights & Access
Water access: Yes
Lot Details
Lot size: 2.94 Acres
South of highway: No
Location
-
Nearby Beaches
-
1 mileCrescent Beach
-
1 mileWades Beach
-
1 mileShell Beach
-
-
Nearby Transportation
-
1 mileShelter Island - Shelter Island Seaplane Base
-
3 milesGreenport - LIRR
-
3 milesGreenport - Hampton Jitney
-
