5 North Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
-
Beds
5
-
Baths
4.5
-
Acres
2.94
-
Sq. ft.
Last Verified:
Mar 6, 2026
Highlights
SHELTER ISLAND 1860 ITALIANATE WITH POOL AND DOCK
Set on 2.94 waterfront acres overlooking West Neck Creek, this 1860 Italianate stands with the quiet assurance of a home that has been well kept and thoughtfully expanded over time. Affectionately named "The Other Havens' House", it was built by the Havens family from wood brought by rail and barge from their lumberyard which was located on The East River in Manhattan, where the United Nations Building is today. From its slightly elevated posi
Home Details
Construction
Property type: Single-family
Property style: Federal
New construction: No
Year built: 1860
Interior Details
Sq. ft: 3,157
Price per square foot: $1,631/sqft
Basement type: Full
Stories: 2
Floors: Hardwood, Tile
Fireplaces: 3
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
Bedrooms: 5
Full bathrooms: 4
Half bathrooms: 1
Bathroom on first floor: Yes
Primary bedroom on first floor: Yes
Other Rooms
Bonus room, Family room/den, Great room, In-law suite/private guest quarters, Laundry room, Library, Office, Studio, Study
Utilities
Heat type: Gas hot air
Central air conditioning: Yes
Financial Details
Price: $5,150,000
Taxes: $26,438/yr
Outdoor Details
Pool & Spa
Pool: Yes
Pool material: Gunite
Parking
Garage: Yes
Attached garage: Yes
Spaces in garage: 2
Outdoor Amenities
Tennis: No
Room for a tennis court: No
Water frontage/View: Waterfront
Outdoor Shower(s): Yes
Sprinkler system: Yes
Dock: Yes
Rights & Access
Water access: Yes
Lot Details
Lot size: 2.94 Acres
South of highway: No
Location
-
Nearby Beaches
-
1 mileCrescent Beach
-
1 mileWades Beach
-
1 mileShell Beach
-
-
Nearby Transportation
-
1 mileShelter Island - Shelter Island Seaplane Base
-
3 milesGreenport - LIRR
-
3 milesGreenport - Hampton Jitney
-
